Kagin-31 is a U.S. Mint-made proof-only striking of the 141-grain, 20-carat Augustus Bechtler obverse die, paired with the C. Bechtler RUTHERF: reverse die. It is generally referred to as a restrike, although the Bechtlers never struck any coins from this die pair, technically making the issue a fantasy piece. It is believed that a total of 15 were struck, with the finest being a gem proof.
| coinage-type | Pioneer & Territorial Gold |
| desg | PR |
| designer | A. & C. Bechtler |
| edge | Plain |
| fineness | 0.8333 |
| material | Gold |
| mintage | 15 |
| ngc-id | 2BA4 |
| obverse-description | 141.G. 20. CARATS. CAROLINA GOLD. |
| pcgs-link | 10124 |
| pcgs-number | 10124 |
| reverse-description | 5 DOLLARS. * C. BECHTLER. AT RUTHERF: |
| variety | A.Bechtler |
| variety-2 | 141 GR, 20C, Chapman Restrike, K-31 |
| year-display | 1831-1842 |